Chewy.com Review ~ Soft Bakes Applesauce Oatmeal Cookies

Hello Furiends,

Chewy.com was so nice they allowed us to pick a product from their March list to review.  After considering my enormous list of food allergens we narrowed it down to the Soft Bakes Applesauce Oatmeal Cookies by Old Mother Hubbard. 

It was a whirlwind of noses, paws, and claws as Pea and I tried to open the box that magically appeared on our doorstep.  Or I should say that I frantically tried to open as Mom and Pea just watched.   Um, some help would have been appreciated.  Ok, Ok, Mom did help loosen the tape a little bitty bit.

Finally!!!  Got it!  There appears to be some yummy smelling goodie in here.

Mom created two different tests to see how the Soft Bakes Applesauce Oatmeal cookies rated with our tastebuds.

Test #1:  Three different cookies are placed on a glass platter.

Which of these 3 treats will be eaten first?

Or

Or

I picked cookie flavor.......Can you guess which one?

Soft Bakes Applesauce Oatmeal.  Followed by Three Dog Bakery Sweet Potato Classic Wafers and last Wet Noses Organic Pumpkin.

 

Test #2: A repeat of Test #1 with my sister performing the tasting.

First choice is Wet Noses Organic Pumpkin.

Interesting,  choice number two is Three Dog Bakery Classic Wafers Sweet Potato.

  In last place is Soft Bakes Applesauce Oatmeal.

 Test #3:  We placed the same 3 cookies in a row.  Right to left  (my right, your left) Soft Bakes Applesauce Oatmeal, Wet Noses Organic Pumpkin, Three Dog Bakery Classic Wafers Sweet Potato.

First choice is..............................Yep, same as test #1 the Soft Bakes Applesauce Oatmeal.

Second choice is..................Yep, you guessed it Three Dog Bakery Classic Wafers Sweet Potato.

Last choice is Wet Noses Organic Pumpkin.  Don't let that fool you because before I knew there were options like these I was gladly gobbling up the Wet Noses Organic Pumpkin.

Test #4: This is a repeat of test #3 with my sister performing the tasting.  Will she make the exact same choices as before just like I did???????????????????????????

First choice is......................................................Can you guess?

Her first choice in this test is the Soft Bakes Applesauce Oatmeal.

The second choice is Three Dog Bakery Classic Wafers Sweet Potato. 

 

Lastly it's Wet Noses Organic Pumpkin.

 

Our test results show that 3 out 4 times the Soft Bakes Applesauce Oatmeal cookies were chosen first.  Which makes me wonder if when my sister did the first test if she didn't just pick the cookie closest to her.  Hmmmmmmm. I guess only she will know the answer to that question because she's napping now after all that hard work.

If anyone is wondering what is in each product here is a list of their ingredients.  Maybe you will want to try one or all of them. 

 Old Mother Hubbard Soft Bakes Applesauce Oatmeal
Whole Wheat Flour, Honey, Canola Oil (preserved with Mixed Tocopherols), Apple Puree, Oatmeal, Cinnamon, Cane Molasses, Natural Vanilla Flavor.

Three Dog Bakery Classic Wafers Sweet Potato
 Rice flour, honey, canola oil, sweet potato powder, millet, cinnamon powder, dried whole egg, dried molasses, baking soda, vanilla powder, baking powder, citric acid (preservative), mixed tocopherals (preservative).

Wet Noses Organic Pumpkin
Organic Rye Flour
Organic Pumpkin
Organic Canola Oil
Organic Ginger
Organic Cinnamon


This review was as fair as we could make it.  We were provided the product by Chewy.com, but we did not let that influence our tastebuds.  Honest :)

THE END :)